Battleship Texas Dry Berth Project: Preserving an Invaluable Place in History
Texas Parks and Wildlife Department (TPWD) is currently moving forward with critical vessel repairs to the Battleship Texas (BB-35). While now committed to making those critical repairs, TPWD maintains the long-term goal of the construction of a dry berth at the Battleship Texas State Historic Site in La Porte, Texas.
In June 2012, the Battleship Texas began taking on water at rates as high as 2,000 gallons per minute due to leaks in her fragile hull. TPWD, together with the Naval Sea Systems Command (NAVSEA), the Texas Historical Commission, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, and the other stakeholders for the dry berth project, determined the most critical repairs necessary for the ship and conducted those repairs. To finance this urgent undertaking, TPWD utilized funds originally allocated for the Battleship Texas Dry Berth Project.
TPWD has been careful to comply with federal regulations set forth by the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA). The recent flooding incidents served as a strong reminder that the Battleship Texas is in need of extensive structural repairs, whether or not she is placed into a dry berth.
In 1948, Battleship Texas became the nation’s first permanent battleship memorial museum, and she was secured in a slip off the Houston Ship Channel adjacent to the San Jacinto Battleground State Historic Site. A veteran of both world wars, she is one-of-a-kind as the only remaining dreadnought. Over the last sixty years, Battleship Texas has been subject to continuous environmental and physical threats while resting in the shallow, brackish waters of the ship channel. To protect and preserve this unique National Historic Landmark, a new dry berth is envisioned to provide her with a permanent home.
In 2008, the Texas Legislature appropriated $25 million for the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department to dry berth the Battleship Texas. In 2009, the Legislative Budget Board approved funding for the dry berth project, provided that the ship was dry berthed in her current location adjacent to the San Jacinto Battleground. The Battleship Texas Foundation (BTF) pledged an additional $4 million toward the dry berth project.
With this funding, TPWD was tasked with accomplishing three things:
- Make only those repairs necessary to get the ship into a dry berth.
- Design and construct a dry berth.
- Place the ship into the dry berth and make her presentable to the public.
Dry Berth Still the Plan; Repairs Necessary First
In 2010, TPWD hired AECOM Technical Services, Inc. (AECOM) to survey the condition of the battleship, provide preliminary design concepts for a dry berth, and conduct the studies necessary to comply with federal environmental and historic preservation regulations.
While conducting the conceptual design, TPWD carried out the studies and processes necessary to meet the requirements of NEPA, as well as Section 106 of NHPA. As part of these two processes, TPWD conducted proactive stakeholder outreach, including a stakeholder workshop, regular consultation meetings (as required by Section 106), and a large-scale public open house. TPWD also put out a formal call for alternatives from the public, but no viable or reasonable design alternatives were received.
In 2011, the project team finalized a Conceptual Design Report that outlines two significant findings:
- Key components of the vessel are in much worse condition than anticipated.
- The cost for each of the dry berth concepts greatly exceed the available budget for the project.
TPWD determined that the available budget for the dry berth project would be insufficient to fund even the vessel repairs, let alone vessel repairs and construction of the dry berth. Therefore, TPWD is in need of additional funding sources to protect and preserve the battleship.
What do the necessary ship repairs entail?
Ship repairs will work toward stabilizing the Battleship Texas in accordance with the U.S. Department of Interior's "Standards for Historic Vessel Preservation," which define stabilization as:
"the act or process of applying measures designed to arrest, retard, or prevent deterioration of a vessel, and to assure its structural integrity. This may include the rendering of the vessel weather resistant and watertight. The essential form of the vessel shall be maintained during this process."
Critical components of the internal structure of the ship have severely deteriorated since her days of active service. For example, the ship's two 1,100-ton engines (together weighing over 4.4 million pounds) are resting on frames that are approximately 80 to 90 percent disintegrated. The frames supporting the boilers, the steering gear, and the aft emergency diesel generator are also targeted for prioritized replacement due to their similarly severe condition.
The degraded steel frames under the heavy machinery will be cut out completely and replaced to original specification where possible, and will be augmented with "doubler" frames otherwise. These "doublers" will be cut to the original specification and attached to the existing deteriorated frames and adjacent steel. While the majority of the work will not involve the replacement of the outer hull plating, the ship's resistance to flooding will be greatly improved by the proposed internal repairs. This is because the replaced frames will create a system of isolated watertight spaces within the hull of the ship. If one space floods due to a hull leak, the water will be confined and unable to flow into adjacent areas. The movement of water within the ship through the existing degraded framework was a major problem during the flooding events of summer 2012, adding significant cost and time to addressing the events.
As available funding permits, the ship will be made as watertight and weather-resistant as appropriate and approved. While a list of prioritized repairs has been developed by the project team, the estimated costs for those repairs are greater than the funding currently available. Repairs will be made in order of priority, until the funding is exhausted. The remainder of the repairs can be addressed if and when additional funding is provided.
As the battleship cannot be moved for the repairs, all repairs must be executed with the ship in her current location. The ship is a historic artifact and a U.S. National Historic Landmark. Great care must be taken to ensure that the cultural significance of the ship is not compromised.
How do the vessel repairs affect the battleship and the outcome of the dry berth project?
- First, when the repair project is complete, there will be very little, if any, changes to the ship that will be visibly identifiable. The repairs to be done are in the interior of the ship where the general public does not have access.
- Second, repairs to the ship will not preclude a dry berth. All of the repairs are necessary regardless of whether the ship stays in her current wet berth or is eventually moved to a dry berth.
- Finally, there will still be repairs necessary to the ship when the immediate repair project is completed (i.e. when the available funding is exhausted). Even so, TPWD will be significantly closer to completing the charge of making the necessary repairs required to get the ship into a protected dry berth.
February 12, 2014: Happy Belated New Year! The holidays have everything a little bit behind, so this report is the first one since late December. While this update is behind, the continuing critical structural repair work on the Battleship Texas is certainly not! Taylor Marine Construction (TMC) worked solidly through the holiday season, remaining busy repairing frames in the aft trimming tank (D-12), the tanks under both engine rooms and the tanks just outboard of both engine rooms. In fact, all of the work in space D-12 is about 95% completed, and the structural work in the spaces just outboard of the engine rooms is 100% complete! All that is left is the frame repair under the engine rooms, and that work is just about 50% complete. Once all the structural work is completed, TMC has to replace the many tons of piping and other equipment that had to be removed to allow the work to be completed. That task alone will take almost 4 months! In addition to the framing work, TMC will be retrofitting and upgrading the hardware on the 4 “monopiles” that moor the Mighty “T” in place starting in March 2014. The existing chains and associated hardware have been damaged over the years, soan upgrade is in order. That work will be completed before the 2014 hurricane season, and unlike the work below decks, the monopile retrofit will be clearly visible by the public. Come on out to the ship and take a look! The structural work inside the ship is on schedule to be completed by late summer of 2014. Stay tuned for another update in the next month or so, and be sure to come on out to the ship on March 15, 2014 to celebrate the Centennial of the commissioning of the ship with a family friendly festival and some good Texas music (see www.battleshiptexas.org for more information).
- Watch a Youtube Video About the Battleship Texas Dry Berth Project (September 2011)
- Project Video Shown at Public Meeting 12-02-28 (February 2012)
- Battleship Texas Project: Structural Repairs and Dry Berth (August 2013)